Alright, let's break this down objectively. We're looking at a bloodlusted battle royale between six peak human/superhuman fighters: Batman, Captain America, Spider-Man, Luke Cage, Daredevil, and Black Panther. "Bloodlusted" means they're fighting to kill with no morals or hesitation, and all are at their peak comic book abilities (no PIS/worfing). Here's how I see it:
Physical Stats Breakdown:
- Strength:
- Spider-Man and Luke Cage are the clear top tiers here, both around 25-ton strength. Spidey is more agile, but Cage is a brick wall.
- Black Panther (enhanced to ~2-5 tons), Captain America (peak human, ~1-2 tons), and Batman (peak human, ~800 lbs-1 ton) are significantly weaker in raw power.
- Daredevil is the weakest here (~400-600 lbs), though his agility helps.
- Durability:
- Luke Cage is bulletproof, resistant to most blunt force, and can tank hits from Spidey.
- Spider-Man is superhumanly durable (takes punches from 50-tonners, survives falls from skyscrapers). Not bulletproof but bullet-resistant because of his speed, reflexes and Spidey sense.
- Black Panther's vibranium suit absorbs kinetic energy, making him near-invulnerable to most attacks but... let's be real. The same way Black Panther puts on his suit is the same way a stronger and faster opponent can take that suit off.
- Batman's armor helps in much the same way BP's suit does - though not nearly as effective. Inside the armor... he's still human.
- Captain America's shield makes him hard to hurt but any opponent with 10-25 ton strength can easily take that shield away - even if they have to take his arms along with the shield. This makes him the 2nd most vulnerable fighter in this group as far as durability is concerned.
- Daredevil is the most fragile and least protected.
- Speed/Reflexes:
- Spider-Man is in a league of his own - dodges bullets after they're fired, moves FTE (faster than eye), and his precog (Spidey-sense) makes him nearly untouchable.
- Daredevil has enhanced reflexes and radar. While he might be physically slower than Cap and BP, his enhancements give him a level of 'Spidey-like' sense - making his Speed/Reflexes a tad superior to Cap/BP.
- Black Panther and Captain America are both peak human (plus). Can dodge bullets with extreme focus and years of experience. No where near Spidey's superhuman levels.
- Batman is peak human, but not superhuman in speed.
- Luke Cage is the slowest here - strong but sluggish.
- Fighting Skill:
- Spider-Man is a skilled 3D fighter. His fighting style cannot be taught because they require Spidey's enhanced abilities, strength, speed and uncanny spider sense. Few characters can defend and go on the offense like Spiderman.
- Batman is arguably the best pure fighter here (master of 127 modern versions of martial arts).
- Black Panther and Captain America are close behind (BP has centuries of warrior training but hampered trying to unlearn century old muscle memory in favor of more modern ways of fighting, Cap has mastered combat, trenches).
- Daredevil is a highly skilled but a level below the elites.
- Luke Cage is a brawler, not a martial artist.
- Gear/Abilities:
- Spider-Man: Webbing (stronger than steel, can restrain 25-tonners), wall-crawling, Spidey-sense (precog), extreme speed, bullet-time reflexes, 10-25 ton strength and a unique/unstoppable 3D fighting style.
- Black Panther: Vibranium suit (absorbs impacts, claws can cut anything), energy daggers, stealth tech.
- Luke Cage: Unbreakable skin, 25-30 ton strength.
- Batman: Gadgets (explosives, smoke pellets, etc.), armor, prep genius.
- Captain America: Vibranium shield (indestructible, ricochets), peak human tactics.
- Daredevil: Radar sense, Billy clubs, agility.
How the Fight Plays Out:
- Spider-Man is the biggest threat due to his speed, precog, strength and webbing. In a bloodlusted fight, he could web everyone's faces/mouths to suffocate them or snap necks with his strength before they can react.
- Black Panther is the second biggest threat - his vibranium suit makes him almost untouchable, and his claws can cut anyone here (including Cage, since vibranium can pierce his skin).
- Luke Cage is a tank but too slow to land hits on Spidey or BP. He could ragdoll Cap, Batman, or Daredevil, but they'd avoid him.
- Batman is outmatched physically against his stronger opponents but his gadgets can cause a lot of problems (e.g., sonic weapons against DD, smoke pellets to obscure vision). Still, he lacks the firepower to put down Cage or Spidey.
- Captain America is deadly with his shield, but in a free-for-all, he can't block everything. His best bet is using the shield to take out - if possible - Batman or Daredevil first.
- Daredevil is the first to die - no durability to survive a hit from Spidey, Cage, or BP.
Final Standings:
- Spider-Man - Too fast, too strong, too unpredictable. His webbing can immobilize everyone including BP (he can web BP at the wrists & forearms, making it impossible to use his claws to cut loose). Bloodlusted Spidey would speed-blitz and snap necks/web-suffocate before others react.
- Black Panther - Vibranium suit protects him from most attacks, and his claws can kill anyone except for Spidey who will see a slow-motion attack against him.
- Luke Cage - Too durable for most to hurt, but too slow to land hits on Spidey or BP. He'd outlast Cap and Batman. He'd lose to Spidey's myriad of enhancements. BP's speed and claws are the deciding reason Luke Cage places third. Take away Panther's claws... Luke demolishes all except Spidey.
- Batman - Gadgets help an awful lot in this battle royale, but he's outclassed in strength and speed against the upper echelon opponents.
- Captain America - Shield gives him a chance, but he lacks the physicals to keep up.
- Daredevil - Dies first.
Winner: Spider-Man.
Spiderman's combination of speed, precog, strength and webbing makes him nearly unbeatable in this lineup. Spidey needs amore challenging group of opponents.